News media still pressing the mute button on womens sports
A 30-year USC/Purdue study finds that television news and ESPNs SportsCenter continue to ignore womens sports and online media coverage isnt much better.
The talented athletes are there. The cheering fans are there. But the media? Nowhere to be found.
This is the reality of womens sports, which continue to be almost entirely excluded from television news and sports highlights shows, according to a USC/Purdue University study published Wednesday in Communication & Sport.
The survey of mens and womens sports news coverage has been conducted every five years since 1989. In the latest study, researchers found that 95% of total television coverage as well as the ESPN highlights show SportsCenter focused on mens sports in 2019. They saw a similar lopsidedness in social media posts and in online sports newsletters coverage, which were included in the report for the first time since researchers began gathering data three decades ago.
One and done: why media coverage matters
The study documented a few bright spots for womens sports, including increasing live televised coverage and prominent news outlets like the Los Angeles Times devoting more resources to womens sports.
But the coverage of womens sports hasnt increased in terms of television news and highlights shows, the more critical components of the larger media apparatus that helps create audiences for sports, said report author Michael Messner.
News media focus on the big three men’s sports football, basketball and baseball creating audience knowledge about and excitement for the same sporting events over and over, explained Messner, a professor of sociology and gender studies at the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences.
Meanwhile, womens sports continue to get short shrift, which is significant when you consider the larger picture of girls and womens efforts to achieve equal opportunities, resources, pay and respect in sports.
Messner and study co-author Cheryl Cooky of Purdue say this missing piece of media coverage is stunting the growth of audience interest in and excitement for womens sports.
Eighty percent of the news and highlights programs in our study devoted zero time for womens sports.
Eighty percent of the news and highlights programs in our study devoted zero time for womens sports, said Cooky, a professor of American studies and womens, gender and sexuality studies. On the rare broadcast when a womens sports story does appear, it is usually a case of one and done a single womens sports story partially eclipsed by a cluster of mens stories that precede it, follow it and are longer in length.
To ensure their data sample included various sports seasons, the authors analyzed three two-week blocs of televised news on three Los Angeles network affiliates in March, July and November 2019, along with three weeks of the one-hour SportsCenter program. For the first time in the studys 30-year history, they also included online daily sports newsletters from networks, including NBC, CBS and ESPN and their associated Twitter accounts.
The inclusion of online coverage was partly in response to assurances by some in the media industry that more coverage of womens sports could be found in online and social media coverage. But the more expansive analysis revealed only slightly more coverage of womens sports, which made up 9% of online newsletter content and 10% of Twitter posts.
Considering the ease of posting content and the relative lack of production and budgetary constraints when compared to TV news, we anticipated more coverage of womens sports in online and social media spaces, Cooky said. We were surprised by how little coverage we found. There just isnt a compelling excuse for that absence.
TV news and highlights shows give perfunctory attention to women athletes
Messner and Cooky found that even the tiny percentage of TV news coverage devoted to womens sports in 2019 was inflated due to a burst of coverage of the U.S. soccer teams victory in the Womens World Cup and to a lesser extent, the U.S. womens tennis competitors at Wimbledon.
When they subtracted just the Womens World Cup coverage from the total, the local television affiliates coverage of womens sports dropped from 5.1% to 4.0% and the airtime on ESPNs SportsCenter devoted to womens sports dropped from 5.4% to 3.5%, a proportion similar to prior iterations of the study.
It isnt just the quantity but also the quality of coverage that needs improvement, said the researchers, who have documented several dramatic shifts in the ways that womens sports are covered.
In the 1990s, they saw coverage that routinely trivialized, insulted and sexualized women athletes. By 2014, that frame had receded and in its place was an attempt at a more respectful framing of womens sports that was delivered in a boring, inflection-free manner the researchers call gender-bland sexism.
Our analysis shows mens sports are the appetizer, the main course and the dessert.
In this recent study, Messner and Cooky looked more closely at the gender-bland pattern, finding that nationalism temporarily elevated successful womens sports into the news as in the Womens World Cup example but that there was little subsequent spillover into increased or higher-quality coverage of other womens sports.
Additionally, the charitable contributions of mens teams and athletes were frequently elevated in news and highlights shows, while women athletes community contributions, including their social justice activism, almost never made the news. These omissions help paint women athletes with a more one-dimensional, gender-bland brush.
Our analysis shows mens sports are the appetizer, the main course and the dessert, and if theres any mention of womens sports it comes across as begrudging eat your vegetables without the kind of bells and whistles and excitement with which they describe mens sports and athletes, Messner said.
Does pandemic-era WNBA enthusiasm equal a turning point? Researchers remain skeptical
The authors acknowledge their analysis took place before the COVID-19 pandemic temporarily forced many athletes off the courts and out of stadiums in 2020. When they returned to the airwaves, ESPN increased its investment in the Women’s National Basketball Association and tripled the number of games it aired across its networks, and the league made headlines for supporting the Black Lives Matter movement. The WNBA recently announced plans for its 25th anniversary this year, including celebrations highlighting the leagues milestones.
Could this represent a turning point for womens sports? After 30 years of data demonstrating the intransigence of sports media, Messner and Cooky are skeptical.
Before the pandemic, many fans took sports for granted; now its clear how much we rely on sports for entertainment and as a form of escape, Cooky said.
While the WNBA successfully capitalized on the fans and the medias hunger for sports over the summer, the medias effort to get back to whats considered normal may once again eclipse women athletes. It remains to be seen whether this moment in history will force the media to reimagine its coverage of womens sports.
Additional authors include LaToya Council of USC and Maria Mears of Purdue University.
Primary funding for this study was provided through a grant from the Womens Sports Foundation. Additional funding was provided by the Center for Feminist Research at the University of Southern California and the Office of the Provost at Purdue University.